Top 1st: Toronto
- R. Davis struck out swinging
- M. Cabrera popped out to second
- J. Bautista flied out to left

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 0, NY Yankees 0  

Bottom 1st: NY Yankees
- B. Gardner struck out swinging
- J. Nix singled to shallow right
- R. Cano singled to shallow right, J. Nix to second
- V. Wells flied out to deep center, J. Nix to third
- K. Youkilis grounded into fielder's choice, R. Cano out at second

0 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 0, NY Yankees 0  

Top 2nd: Toronto
- E. Encarnacion flied out to left center
- J.P. Arencibia flied out to left
- B. Lawrie flied out to deep center

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 0, NY Yankees 0  

Bottom 2nd: NY Yankees
- T. Hafner flied out to left
- I. Suzuki singled to shallow left
- E. Nunez struck out looking
- C. Stewart lined out to shortstop

0 runs, 1 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 0, NY Yankees 0  

Top 3rd: Toronto
- M. DeRosa popped out to shallow left
- M. Izturis singled to shortstop
- E. Bonifacio doubled to shallow left, M. Izturis to third
- R. Davis grounded out to shortstop, M. Izturis scored, E. Bonifacio to third
- M. Cabrera grounded out to first

1 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 1, NY Yankees 0  

Bottom 3rd: NY Yankees
- B. Gardner grounded out to shortstop
- J. Nix flied out to center
- R. Cano struck out swinging

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 1, NY Yankees 0  

Top 4th: Toronto
- J. Bautista homered to deep left
- E. Encarnacion singled to shallow left
- J.P. Arencibia grounded out to second, E. Encarnacion to second
- E. Encarnacion to third on passed ball
- B. Lawrie flied out to right, E. Encarnacion scored on catcher C. Stewart's fielding error
- M. DeRosa singled to pitcher
- M. Izturis singled to shallow right, M. DeRosa to second
- E. Bonifacio flied out to center

2 runs, 4 hits, 1 errors
Toronto 3, NY Yankees 0  

Bottom 4th: NY Yankees
- V. Wells walked
- K. Youkilis walked, V. Wells to second
- T. Hafner homered to deep right center, V. Wells and K. Youkilis scored
- I. Suzuki flied out to right
- E. Nunez singled to right center
- C. Stewart flied out to center
- B. Gardner singled to shallow center, E. Nunez to second
- J. Nix lined out to shortstop

3 runs, 3 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 3, NY Yankees 3  

Top 5th: Toronto
- R. Davis singled to shortstop
- M. Cabrera singled to shallow left center, R. Davis to second
- J. Bautista flied out to shallow center
- E. Encarnacion flied out to left
- J.P. Arencibia struck out swinging

0 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 3, NY Yankees 3  

Bottom 5th: NY Yankees
- R. Cano flied out to center
- V. Wells popped out to second
- K. Youkilis struck out looking

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 3, NY Yankees 3  

Top 6th: Toronto
- B. Lawrie homered to deep right
- M. DeRosa grounded out to shortstop
- M. Izturis grounded out to shortstop
- E. Bonifacio struck out swinging

1 runs, 1 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 4, NY Yankees 3  

Bottom 6th: NY Yankees
- T. Hafner flied out to deep center
- I. Suzuki singled to shallow left center
- E. Nunez popped out to first
- C. Stewart reached on bunt single to third, I. Suzuki to second
- B. Gardner struck out swinging

0 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 4, NY Yankees 3  

Top 7th: Toronto
- R. Davis grounded out to third
- M. Cabrera struck out swinging
- J. Bautista flied out to deep center

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 4, NY Yankees 3  

Bottom 7th: NY Yankees
- E. Rogers relieved J.A. Happ
- J. Nix lined out to shallow right
- R. Cano doubled to shallow right
- V. Wells singled to shallow center, R. Cano scored
- K. Youkilis grounded out to third, V. Wells to second
- B. Cecil relieved E. Rogers
- V. Wells stole third
- T. Hafner tripled to deep center, V. Wells scored
- I. Suzuki grounded out to second

2 runs, 3 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 4, NY Yankees 5  

Top 8th: Toronto
- E. Encarnacion lined out to center
- J.P. Arencibia grounded out to shortstop
- B. Lawrie popped out to shallow right

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 4, NY Yankees 5  

Bottom 8th: NY Yankees
- E. Nunez lined out to shallow right
- C. Stewart grounded out to third
- B. Gardner struck out swinging

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 4, NY Yankees 5  

Top 9th: Toronto
- J. Chamberlain relieved C. Sabathia
- C. Rasmus hit for M. DeRosa
- C. Rasmus at designated hitter
- C. Rasmus struck out swinging
- M. Izturis singled to shallow left
- M. Kawasaki ran for M. Izturis
- E. Bonifacio singled, M. Kawasaki to second
- R. Davis flied out to shallow right
- M. Cabrera grounded into fielder's choice, M. Kawasaki out at third, E. Bonifacio to second

0 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 4, NY Yankees 5