Top 1st: Toronto
- M. McCoy singled to shallow center
- K. Johnson struck out swinging
- J. Bautista struck out swinging
- E. Encarnacion singled to shallow left, M. McCoy to third
- B. Lawrie grounded into fielder's choice, E. Encarnacion out at second

0 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 0, NY Yankees 0  

Bottom 1st: NY Yankees
- B. Gardner walked
- B. Gardner stole second
- D. Jeter grounded out to third
- M. Teixeira singled, B. Gardner to third, B. Gardner scored on shortstop M. McCoy's fielding error
- A. Rodriguez struck out swinging
- R. Cano grounded out to second

1 runs, 1 hits, 1 errors
Toronto 0, NY Yankees 1  

Top 2nd: Toronto
- M. Teahen singled to shallow center, M. Teahen to second on center fielder B. Gardner's fielding error
- J. Molina flied out to right
- J.P. Arencibia popped out to first
- D. Wise struck out swinging

0 runs, 1 hits, 1 errors
Toronto 0, NY Yankees 1  

Bottom 2nd: NY Yankees
- N. Swisher popped out to shortstop
- A. Jones struck out looking
- R. Martin lined out to third

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 0, NY Yankees 1  

Top 3rd: Toronto
- M. McCoy struck out swinging
- K. Johnson grounded out to first
- J. Bautista lined out to right

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 0, NY Yankees 1  

Bottom 3rd: NY Yankees
- J. Montero singled
- B. Gardner hit by pitch, J. Montero to second
- D. Jeter homered to deep left, J. Montero and B. Gardner scored
- M. Teixeira flied out to left center
- A. Rodriguez flied out to center
- R. Cano lined out to left

3 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 0, NY Yankees 4  

Top 4th: Toronto
- E. Encarnacion singled to shallow right center
- B. Lawrie walked, E. Encarnacion to second
- M. Teahen doubled to left, E. Encarnacion scored, B. Lawrie to third
- J. Molina grounded out to shortstop, B. Lawrie scored
- J.P. Arencibia grounded out to third
- D. Wise struck out looking

2 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 2, NY Yankees 4  

Bottom 4th: NY Yankees
- N. Swisher grounded out to shortstop
- A. Jones grounded out to third
- R. Martin flied out to right

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 2, NY Yankees 4  

Top 5th: Toronto
- M. McCoy struck out swinging
- K. Johnson grounded out to second
- J. Bautista popped out to catcher

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 2, NY Yankees 4  

Bottom 5th: NY Yankees
- J. Montero singled to shallow left
- B. Gardner flied out to shallow right center
- D. Jeter struck out swinging
- M. Teixeira grounded into fielder's choice, J. Montero out at second

0 runs, 1 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 2, NY Yankees 4  

Top 6th: Toronto
- E. Encarnacion struck out swinging
- B. Lawrie flied out to right
- M. Teahen struck out looking

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 2, NY Yankees 4  

Bottom 6th: NY Yankees
- A. Rodriguez homered to deep right
- R. Cano grounded out to second
- N. Swisher flied out to deep left center
- A. Jones grounded out to third

1 runs, 1 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 2, NY Yankees 5  

Top 7th: Toronto
- J. Molina struck out swinging
- J.P. Arencibia singled to shallow center
- D. Wise fouled out to shallow left
- M. McCoy grounded into fielder's choice, J.P. Arencibia out at second

0 runs, 1 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 2, NY Yankees 5  

Bottom 7th: NY Yankees
- J. Litsch relieved B. Cecil
- R. Martin struck out swinging
- J. Montero safe at first on first baseman E. Encarnacion's fielding error
- E. Nunez at designated hitter
- E. Nunez ran for E. Nunez
- E. Nunez to second on wild pitch
- B. Gardner walked
- D. Jeter flied out to right
- M. Teixeira struck out swinging

0 runs, 0 hits, 1 errors
Toronto 2, NY Yankees 5  

Top 8th: Toronto
- E. Nunez at designated hitter
- K. Johnson struck out swinging
- R. Soriano relieved C. Sabathia
- J. Bautista homered to deep left
- E. Encarnacion singled to shallow left center
- B. Lawrie flied out to deep center
- M. Teahen grounded out to second

1 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 3, NY Yankees 5  

Bottom 8th: NY Yankees
- J. Rauch relieved J. Litsch
- A. Rodriguez grounded out to third
- R. Cano singled to shallow right
- N. Swisher homered to deep right, R. Cano scored
- A. Jones grounded out to third
- R. Martin walked
- R. Lewis relieved J. Rauch
- E. Nunez singled, R. Martin to second
- B. Gardner walked, R. Martin to third, E. Nunez to second
- D. Jeter singled to shallow center, R. Martin and E. Nunez scored, B. Gardner to second, B. Gardner to third on center fielder D. Wise's fielding error
- M. Teixeira flied out to right

4 runs, 4 hits, 1 errors
Toronto 3, NY Yankees 9  

Top 9th: Toronto
- B. Laird at third
- C. Dickerson in left field
- C. Wade relieved R. Soriano
- E. Thames at designated hitter
- E. Thames hit for E. Thames
- E. Thames struck out swinging
- J.P. Arencibia walked
- D. Wise struck out swinging
- M. McCoy popped out to second

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Toronto 3, NY Yankees 9