Top 1st: Cleveland
- M. Bourn grounded bunt out to pitcher
- M. Aviles singled
- A. Cabrera struck out swinging
- M. Aviles to second on wild pitch
- N. Swisher struck out looking

0 runs, 1 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 0, NY Yankees 0  

Bottom 1st: NY Yankees
- B. Gardner grounded out to first
- R. Cano grounded out to shortstop
- M. Teixeira walked
- T. Hafner struck out looking

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 0, NY Yankees 0  

Top 2nd: Cleveland
- M. Reynolds struck out swinging
- C. Santana singled to shallow left
- R. Raburn walked, C. Santana to second
- Y. Gomes grounded into fielder's choice, C. Santana to third, R. Raburn out at second
- D. Stubbs flied out to left

0 runs, 1 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 0, NY Yankees 0  

Bottom 2nd: NY Yankees
- L. Overbay flied out to left
- I. Suzuki grounded out to shortstop
- D. Adams grounded out to shortstop

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 0, NY Yankees 0  

Top 3rd: Cleveland
- M. Bourn singled to shallow center
- M. Aviles singled to shallow right, M. Bourn to second
- A. Cabrera sacrificed to pitcher, M. Bourn to third, M. Aviles to second
- N. Swisher grounded into fielder's choice, M. Bourn scored, M. Aviles out at third
- M. Reynolds grounded out to pitcher

1 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 1, NY Yankees 0  

Bottom 3rd: NY Yankees
- R. Brignac singled to right center
- A. Romine singled to shallow center, R. Brignac to second
- B. Gardner walked, R. Brignac to third, A. Romine to second
- R. Cano grounded into fielder's choice, R. Brignac out at home, A. Romine to third, B. Gardner to second
- M. Teixeira homered to right, A. Romine, B. Gardner and R. Cano scored
- T. Hafner flied out to left center
- L. Overbay singled to shallow center
- I. Suzuki singled to shallow center, L. Overbay to second
- D. Adams flied out to right

4 runs, 5 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 1, NY Yankees 4  

Top 4th: Cleveland
- C. Santana grounded out to shortstop
- R. Raburn grounded out to shortstop
- Y. Gomes grounded out to third

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 1, NY Yankees 4  

Bottom 4th: NY Yankees
- A. Romine grounded out to shortstop
- B. Gardner struck out swinging

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 1, NY Yankees 4  

Top 5th: Cleveland
- D. Stubbs doubled to deep right center
- M. Bourn singled, D. Stubbs to third
- M. Aviles hit sacrifice fly to shallow center, D. Stubbs scored
- A. Cabrera grounded out to second, M. Bourn to second
- M. Bourn to third on wild pitch
- N. Swisher walked
- M. Reynolds walked, N. Swisher to second
- C. Santana ground rule double, M. Bourn and N. Swisher scored, M. Reynolds to third
- S. Kelley relieved A. Pettitte
- M. Brantley hit for R. Raburn
- M. Brantley walked
- Y. Gomes popped out to shallow right

3 runs, 3 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 4, NY Yankees 4  

Bottom 5th: NY Yankees
- A. Cabrera at shortstop
- M. Aviles at shortstop
- J. Kipnis at second
- M. Brantley in left field
- R. Cano singled to shallow right
- M. Teixeira struck out swinging
- T. Hafner popped out to third
- L. Overbay grounded out to second

0 runs, 1 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 4, NY Yankees 4  

Top 6th: Cleveland
- D. Stubbs struck out swinging
- M. Aviles popped out to right center

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 4, NY Yankees 4  

Bottom 6th: NY Yankees
- I. Suzuki walked
- D. Adams grounded out to third, I. Suzuki to third
- R. Brignac struck out swinging
- I. Suzuki to third
- A. Romine stole second
- B. Gardner singled to shortstop, I. Suzuki and A. Romine scored, B. Gardner to second advancing on throw, B. Gardner to third on pitcher J. Masterson's throwing error
- R. Cano grounded out to second

2 runs, 2 hits, 1 errors
Cleveland 4, NY Yankees 6  

Top 7th: Cleveland
- J. Chamberlain relieved S. Kelley
- J. Kipnis walked
- N. Swisher flied out to left
- M. Reynolds struck out swinging
- J. Kipnis stole second
- C. Santana struck out swinging

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 4, NY Yankees 6  

Bottom 7th: NY Yankees
- M. Teixeira grounded out to first
- T. Hafner homered to deep right
- C. Allen relieved J. Masterson
- L. Overbay walked
- I. Suzuki flied out to right center
- D. Adams struck out swinging

1 runs, 1 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 4, NY Yankees 7  

Top 8th: Cleveland
- V. Wells in left field
- I. Suzuki in right field
- J. Nix at third
- D. Robertson relieved J. Chamberlain
- M. Brantley flied out to left
- Y. Gomes grounded out to third
- D. Stubbs grounded out to shortstop

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 4, NY Yankees 7  

Bottom 8th: NY Yankees
- J. Smith relieved C. Allen
- R. Brignac doubled to center
- A. Romine sacrificed to first, R. Brignac to third
- B. Gardner grounded out to second
- R. Cano flied out to right center

0 runs, 1 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 4, NY Yankees 7  

Top 9th: Cleveland
- M. Rivera relieved D. Robertson
- M. Bourn singled to shallow left center
- M. Aviles grounded into fielder's choice, M. Bourn out at second
- M. Aviles to second on fielder's indifference
- J. Kipnis struck out swinging
- N. Swisher flied out to left

0 runs, 1 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 4, NY Yankees 7