Top 1st: Cleveland
- M. Brantley struck out swinging
- A. Cabrera struck out looking
- J. Kipnis singled to shallow center
- J. Lopez struck out swinging

0 runs, 1 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 0, NY Yankees 0  

Bottom 1st: NY Yankees
- C. Granderson walked
- C. Granderson stole second
- N. Swisher struck out swinging
- A. Rodriguez walked
- R. Cano struck out swinging
- M. Teixeira popped out to third

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 0, NY Yankees 0  

Top 2nd: Cleveland
- C. Santana safe at first on third baseman A. Rodriguez's throwing error
- S. Duncan doubled to right center, C. Santana scored
- C. Kotchman struck out swinging
- L. Marson grounded out to shortstop, S. Duncan to third
- A. Cunningham walked
- A. Cunningham caught stealing, pitcher to first to shortstop

1 runs, 1 hits, 1 errors
Cleveland 1, NY Yankees 0  

Bottom 2nd: NY Yankees
- R. Ibanez grounded out to second
- E. Chavez grounded out to second
- R. Martin struck out looking

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 1, NY Yankees 0  

Top 3rd: Cleveland
- M. Brantley struck out looking
- A. Cabrera struck out swinging
- J. Kipnis grounded out to second

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 1, NY Yankees 0  

Bottom 3rd: NY Yankees
- J. Nix struck out swinging
- C. Granderson flied out to deep right center
- N. Swisher flied out to right

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 1, NY Yankees 0  

Top 4th: Cleveland
- J. Lopez grounded out to shortstop
- C. Santana struck out looking
- S. Duncan popped out to second

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 1, NY Yankees 0  

Bottom 4th: NY Yankees
- A. Rodriguez struck out swinging
- R. Cano singled to shallow right
- M. Teixeira struck out looking
- R. Ibanez walked, R. Cano to second
- E. Chavez doubled to left center, R. Cano and R. Ibanez scored
- R. Martin grounded out to second

2 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 1, NY Yankees 2  

Top 5th: Cleveland
- C. Kotchman singled to pitcher
- C. Eppley relieved A. Pettitte
- L. Marson singled, C. Kotchman to second
- A. Cunningham sacrificed to first, C. Kotchman to third, L. Marson to second
- C. Rapada relieved C. Eppley
- M. Brantley grounded into fielder's choice, C. Kotchman out at home, L. Marson to third
- A. Cabrera singled to shallow left, L. Marson scored, M. Brantley to second
- J. Kipnis singled to shallow left center, M. Brantley scored, A. Cabrera to third
- F. Garcia relieved C. Rapada
- J. Kipnis stole second
- J. Lopez struck out swinging

2 runs, 4 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 3, NY Yankees 2  

Bottom 5th: NY Yankees
- J. Nix struck out looking
- C. Granderson flied out to right center
- N. Swisher flied out to left

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 3, NY Yankees 2  

Top 6th: Cleveland
- C. Santana popped out to left center
- S. Duncan fouled out to shallow left
- C. Kotchman struck out swinging

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 3, NY Yankees 2  

Bottom 6th: NY Yankees
- S. Choo in right field
- A. Cunningham in left field
- A. Rodriguez doubled to shallow right
- R. Cano homered to deep left, A. Rodriguez scored
- M. Teixeira flied out to left
- R. Ibanez popped out to shallow right
- E. Chavez walked
- R. Martin grounded into fielder's choice, E. Chavez out at second

2 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 3, NY Yankees 4  

Top 7th: Cleveland
- L. Marson lined out to right
- A. Cunningham popped out to shortstop
- M. Brantley grounded out to first

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 3, NY Yankees 4  

Bottom 7th: NY Yankees
- J. Smith relieved U. Jimenez
- J. Nix grounded out to shortstop
- C. Granderson struck out swinging
- N. Swisher struck out swinging

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 3, NY Yankees 4  

Top 8th: Cleveland
- D. Robertson relieved F. Garcia
- A. Cabrera grounded out to first
- J. Kipnis struck out looking
- J. Lopez struck out swinging

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 3, NY Yankees 4  

Bottom 8th: NY Yankees
- V. Pestano relieved J. Smith
- A. Rodriguez grounded out to second
- R. Cano singled to shortstop
- M. Teixeira grounded into fielder's choice, R. Cano out at second
- R. Ibanez singled to shallow left, M. Teixeira to second
- D. Wise ran for R. Ibanez
- E. Chavez singled to shallow right, M. Teixeira scored, D. Wise to second
- R. Martin struck out swinging

1 runs, 3 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 3, NY Yankees 5  

Top 9th: Cleveland
- E. Chavez at first
- M. Teixeira at first
- D. Wise in left field
- R. Soriano relieved D. Robertson
- L. Chisenhall hit for C. Santana
- L. Chisenhall at designated hitter
- L. Chisenhall singled to right
- S. Choo walked, L. Chisenhall to second
- C. Kotchman lined out to left
- L. Marson singled to shallow left, L. Chisenhall to third, S. Choo to second
- J. Damon hit for A. Cunningham
- J. Damon struck out swinging
- M. Brantley walked, L. Chisenhall scored, S. Choo to third, L. Marson to second
- A. Cabrera flied out to left

1 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
Cleveland 4, NY Yankees 5