Top 1st: NY Yankees
- D. Jeter grounded out to shortstop
- C. Granderson struck out looking
- M. Teixeira grounded out to third

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 0, Toronto 0  

Bottom 1st: Toronto
- M. McCoy singled to center
- E. Thames struck out swinging
- J. Bautista singled to right, M. McCoy to third
- E. Encarnacion grounded into fielder's choice, M. McCoy scored, J. Bautista out at second
- E. Encarnacion stole second
- A. Lind struck out swinging

1 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 0, Toronto 1  

Top 2nd: NY Yankees
- R. Cano singled to left, R. Cano out at second
- N. Swisher grounded out to third
- E. Chavez grounded out to third

0 runs, 1 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 0, Toronto 1  

Bottom 2nd: Toronto
- B. Lawrie grounded out to second
- C. Rasmus struck out swinging
- J.P. Arencibia popped out to shortstop

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 0, Toronto 1  

Top 3rd: NY Yankees
- J. Posada grounded out to second
- R. Martin struck out swinging
- B. Gardner walked
- B. Gardner stole second
- B. Gardner stole third
- D. Jeter struck out swinging

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 0, Toronto 1  

Bottom 3rd: Toronto
- K. Johnson singled to shallow left
- M. McCoy reached on bunt single to first, K. Johnson to second
- E. Thames flied out to deep center, K. Johnson to third
- J. Bautista walked, M. McCoy to second
- E. Encarnacion grounded into double play pitcher to catcher to first, K. Johnson out at home

0 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 0, Toronto 1  

Top 4th: NY Yankees
- C. Granderson walked
- M. Teixeira grounded into fielder's choice, C. Granderson out at second
- R. Cano grounded into fielder's choice, M. Teixeira out at second
- N. Swisher doubled to center, R. Cano scored
- E. Chavez homered to deep center, N. Swisher scored
- J. Posada flied out to center

3 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 3, Toronto 1  

Bottom 4th: Toronto
- A. Lind singled to center
- B. Lawrie struck out swinging
- C. Rasmus struck out swinging
- J.P. Arencibia flied out to left

0 runs, 1 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 3, Toronto 1  

Top 5th: NY Yankees
- R. Martin grounded out to shortstop
- B. Gardner grounded out to second
- D. Jeter struck out looking

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 3, Toronto 1  

Bottom 5th: Toronto
- K. Johnson singled to shallow center
- M. McCoy struck out swinging
- E. Thames struck out swinging
- J. Bautista walked, K. Johnson to second
- E. Encarnacion walked, K. Johnson to third, J. Bautista to second
- A. Lind doubled to left, K. Johnson, J. Bautista and E. Encarnacion scored
- B. Lawrie singled to pitcher, A. Lind to third
- C. Rasmus grounded out to pitcher

3 runs, 3 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 3, Toronto 4  

Top 6th: NY Yankees
- J. Litsch relieved D. McGowan
- C. Granderson grounded out to second
- M. Teixeira flied out to shallow left center
- R. Cano doubled to left
- N. Swisher singled to shallow left, R. Cano scored
- E. Chavez grounded into fielder's choice, N. Swisher out at second

1 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 4, Toronto 4  

Bottom 6th: Toronto
- J.P. Arencibia grounded out to shortstop
- K. Johnson singled to center
- M. McCoy singled to shallow right, K. Johnson to second
- E. Thames struck out looking
- J. Bautista walked, K. Johnson to third, M. McCoy to second
- L. Ayala relieved C. Sabathia
- E. Encarnacion lined out to center

0 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 4, Toronto 4  

Top 7th: NY Yankees
- J. Posada grounded out to second
- R. Martin grounded out to third
- B. Gardner flied out to deep center

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 4, Toronto 4  

Bottom 7th: Toronto
- R. Soriano relieved L. Ayala
- A. Lind struck out swinging
- B. Lawrie struck out swinging
- C. Rasmus struck out swinging

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 4, Toronto 4  

Top 8th: NY Yankees
- C. Janssen relieved J. Litsch
- D. Jeter grounded out to second
- C. Granderson popped out to shortstop
- M. Teixeira struck out swinging

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 4, Toronto 4  

Bottom 8th: Toronto
- D. Robertson relieved R. Soriano
- J.P. Arencibia doubled to left
- D. Wise ran for J.P. Arencibia
- K. Johnson walked
- M. McCoy struck out looking
- E. Thames grounded into fielder's choice, D. Wise to third, K. Johnson out at second
- J. Bautista intentionally walked, E. Thames to second
- E. Encarnacion flied out to right

0 runs, 1 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 4, Toronto 4  

Top 9th: NY Yankees
- J. Molina catching
- R. Cano flied out to shallow center
- N. Swisher grounded out to second
- E. Chavez grounded out to second

0 runs, 0 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 4, Toronto 4  

Bottom 9th: Toronto
- B. Logan relieved D. Robertson
- A. Lind doubled to right
- A. Loewen ran for A. Lind
- B. Lawrie intentionally walked
- C. Rasmus grounded into fielder's choice, A. Loewen out at third, B. Lawrie to second
- C. Wade relieved B. Logan
- J. Molina singled to center, B. Lawrie scored, C. Rasmus to second

1 runs, 2 hits, 0 errors
NY Yankees 4, Toronto 5